Телемахида

яю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
57 =0?@02;5=89 AB@5<3;02, GC64-8A:CAAB20 157-=02K:>2 45;L=KE; =5 ?>AB>O=AB20 ?@52@0B5=, 8-B25@4>AB8 2=5 ;53:>;L 5ABL <54;5= :>-1;03C, B2>@8BL-7;>, 83@C-BIC ?@8AB@0AB5=; '0OBL 2A53> >B-A51O, =>-157-?><>I8 @5OBLAO 2 1574=K: AQ 6 8-A85 8 B> C:@0A8 ?@8<. 2>A:@8;OO A0<0, CB25@48 ?0@8BL 70-<8@><, !;>3 «48AA88» 2548 AB>?>9 2 $5=5;>=>25 A;>35: / =5-A@02=88BLAO E>IC ?@>A;02;5==K< B>;L AB8E>?52F0<: !;CEC @>AA89A:>4>18O B>:<> ?@54AB02;N, 0 3@><>3;0A=KE 2 =0A 87>I@N 4>AB830BL A>25@H5=AB20. >@5! G5425@65=K G0AB>? '0AB> 2;O5BAO 2 A5B8 =5-G0O: N48 ?@>=K@=K :>@KABL 8 ;N1OI8 8E >:@C60NB; >1@K5 2A5 >BAB0NB >B =8E >B;CG0OAL >A>1=>, "5< GB> >=8 =5-C<5NB ;0A:0BL 8-:070BLAO CA;C6=K: >1@K5 64CB, ?>:0 =5 27KICBAO 8 ?@87>2CBAO, 3>AC40@8 ?>GB8 =5-A?>A>1=K A=8A:820BL >=KE. ;K5 6, A5B82, ACBL A<5;K, >1<0=G82K, 45@7:8, !:>@K 2:@0ABLAO, 2>-2A5< C3>640BL, ?@8B2>@OBLAO 8A:CA=K, !45;0BL 3>B>2K 2AQ, GB>-?@>B82=> A>25AB8, G5AB8, ">;L:> 1 AB@0AB8 8< C4>2>;8BL 2 A0<>45@602=><. ! 7;>?>;CG5= F0@L, GB> B>;L >B:@KB 7;KE-:>20@AB20<: = ?>381, :>340 ;0A:0B5;LAB2 =5 >B@5205B, =5 ;N18B 2A5E 25I0NI8E 8AB8=C A<5;>. * * * A5 3>AC40@8, 2A5340 :>B>@K ?@5A?5NI8 1K;8, !CBL =5-25AL<0 70 B5< A2>53> 1;065=AB20 4>AB>9=K: 530 ?>@B8B 8E, 0 25;8G85 C?>5205B. !G0AB8O :>;L-65 B515, ?> 2A5E ?>1545 =5AG0AB89! ?@8-2A5340H=59 ?0AB59 1K2H8E! "K C2848HL D0:C 5I5; B2>O-65 8-A;020 @52>7=5A5BAO 4>-A0 72574 ?>=515A=KE. C45HL-65 BK :>340 4@C38< 2;0AB5;8= G5;>25:0<, 4>1@>45B5;L<8 >BG8<8 ?@028BL <8@=>5 F0@AB2>, ><=8, GB>-A0< 1K; A;01, 154=, AB@064CI @02=> :0:->=K, !;04:> B515 40-1K205B 2A5< 8< 45;0BL >B@04C, >440==KE ?@O<> ;N18, ?@>:;8=09 ;0A:0B5;LAB20 2@54=K, 0 8 7=09 ?@8B><, GB> 25;8:8< 1C45HL ?>AB>;L:C, "K ?>A:>;L:C 2 AB@5<8B5;LAB20E 2A5E 1KBL AB0=5HL C<5@5=, 2A5340 1>4@, E@01@, ?>15640BL :8?OI85 AB@0AB8. * * * :C?5 B>340 6 ?@8 =59 CA<>B@8;-O AK=>G:0 -@>B0, >9 ;5B0; A2>5O 2:@C3 <0B5@8 :@8;KH5: ?>@E><. %>BL =0-;8G8H:5 53> ?@51K20;0 @CABL, AO 1;03>;5?=>ABL, 8-2AO 25A5;>ABL ;N157=0 <;045=AB20, ">;L:> 6 2 3;075=:0E 53> 6 =5 7=0N GB>->AB@>5 1K;>, / >B-G53> B@5?5B0; 8 2=CB@L ?@5157<5@=> 1>O;AO. @O =0-<5=O, CA<5E0;AO >=; => <>6=> ?@8<5B8BL, 'B> B>B CA<5E ;C:02, @C30B5;5=, 7>; A>2>:C?=>. K=O; 87-BC;0 >= B>340, =5 <54;O, 7;0B>3> !B@5;C >4=C, C-=53> 87 1K2H8E, ?@5>AB@CN >=C; C:-A2>9 =0?@O3, 8-E>B5; C65 2>=78BL <=5-BC 2 ?5@A8, 0: 2=570?C O28;0AL ?@8B>< 0;;040 A M384><, <5=O 70I8B8;0, A8< >B-AB@5;K ?>:@K20O. 7>@ 1>38=8 A5O =5-8<5; :@0A>BK 65=>;8G=K, ?@5;5AB=KO =538 B>O, :0:CN ?@8<5B8; 0 D@>48B8=>< O ;8F5 8-2>-2=5H=59 >A0=:5; >, =0?@>B82, :@0A>BC ?@>AB>B>9 =5@0482C 8-A:@><=C: K;> 2AQ-206=> 2 =59, 1;03>@>4=>, :@5?:>, A0=>2=>, !8;K 8A?>;=L, 8A?>;=L 8-25;8G8O 2 <. "0 >B--@>B0 AB@5;0, =5-2>7<>3H8 ?@>18BL A:2>7L-M3840, 0;0 =0-75<;N BCB, 157 2AO:8 A>459=>AB8, BI5B=>. "> -@>B 2 4>A04C ?@8O2 2>74>E=C; ?@5BO6:>: !BK4=> 1K;> 515645==0. «@>GL >BAN4C, 0;;040 5GL <0;LG8: ?@>45@7:89! C45HL 2A5340 ?>15640BL A5@4F0 548=AB25==> ?>4;K, N1OI8 ?0G5 15AG5AB=K B2>8E ;N1>A;0AB89 CB5E8, 565;8 ABK4, F5;>1@>45B5;L 8-A;02C»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«@0?>@K A@8=LB5 4>;>9, 2=87-8-?0@CAK, 4@C6=> 3@518B5». !B0;8 >=8 B>340 3@5ABL A8;L=> 25A;0<8 2A5<8; K ?@>1@0;8AL <56 :0<=59 B0: 157-2@540 8-=0?0AB8, A8; C-=53>, A>AB>8B 2 G5< F0@A:0 45@602=>ABL? = >B25I0;: F0@L 2;0AB5= 5ABL 2> 2A5< =04-=0@>4><; > 70:>=K =04-=8< 2> 2A5< 65 2;0AB=K :>=5G=>. >IL 53> A0<>45@6=0 548=AB25==> 4>1@>5 45;0BL; !2O70=K @C:8 8<55B >= =0 2AO:>5 7;>5. E 70:>=K 2>-2;0ABL 54 ?>25@ONB, 0: ?@54@0389 70;>3 87 2A5E 2> A25B5 70;>3>2; "0: GB>1->=-1K; >B5F ?>4G8=5==K< 2A5< 8-?>4@CG=K<. %>I5B 0:>=, 40->48= G5;>25:, 70 ABL 8-<5@=>ABL, !;C68B <=>38E B>;L ;N459 1;03>45=AB28N ?0G5, 565;8 <=>385 ;N48 B>;L, 70 154=>ABL 8-@01AB2>, >4;> 3>@4>ABL 8-=53C ;LABOB >4=>3> G5;>25:0. &0@L =5 4>;65= 8<5BL =8G53> A25@LE 2 >1I5AB25 ?@>G8E, 0725 GB>-=C6=> 53> >1;53G8BL >B-B@C40 <=>3>45;L=0, 2?5G0B;5BL 2> 2A5E ?>GB5=85 1;03>3>259=>, 0: : 1;NAB8B5;N 2A5E ?>;>65==KE 70:>=>2. ?@>G5<, F0@N 1KBL 4>;6=> B@57259HC, <=55 @>A:>H=C, >;55 GC64C ?KH=>AB8, =565;8 ?@>AB>;N48=C. >;LH5 1>30BAB20 5AB>8B, > ?@5AB8, A;02K, : B>1@>45B5;8 1>;LH5, 565;8 ABO6CB :>;L A8E ?@>G85 2A5 G5;>25:8. =5 >= 4>;65= 1KBL 70I8B=8: >B5G5AB2C <8;C, >8=AB20< 2A5< ?@542>48B5;L, 8-A8< 25@LE>2=K9 =0G0;L=8:; =CB@L AC48O, GB>1-?>4AC4=K< 1KBL-4>1@K<, @07C<=K<, AG0AB;82K<. >38 F0@5< 53> =5-545;0;8 2 ?>;L7C; = 5ABL F0@L, GB>1 1K; G5;>25: 2A5< ;N4O< 2708<=>: N4O< A2>5 >B4020BL >= 4>;65= F5;>5 2@58 ?>?5G5=8O, 2AQ 8-CA5@485 ;N4O<; = ?>B>;8:C 4>AB>8= F0@8BL, ?>:>;8:C =5-BI8BAO 0-A515, 40 ?@540ABAO 4>1@C 2A5=0@>4=C. * * * ?>B>< ?@54A540B5;L =0< ?@54;>68; B@8-7040G8, >8 @5H8BL ?> 8=>52K< ?@028;0< 2A5 =04;560;>. 5@20O A8E: :B> 2>;L=59H89 5ABL 87 2A5E G5;>25:>2? ">B >B25I0;, GB> F0@L 25@LE>2=C 45@602C 81548B5;L 5ABL 2A5340 =04-A2>8<8 2@030<8. > 4@C3>9, GB> B> G5;>25: ?@5157<5@=> 1>30BK9, >9 4>2>;LAB2>20BL 2A5 A2>8 ?>65;0=8O <>65B. !88 <=8;8, GB>-B>B, :>B>@K9 5ABL =5-65=0BK9 ?CB5H5AB2C5B 687=L 2AN-A2>N 2 GC65AB@0==K5 75<;8, 5 ?>4G8=5= >B=N4L =8:0:>3> =0@>40 70:>=0<. "5 A>45@60;8, GB>-20@20@ B> 2 ;5AC ?@51K20O9 725@8=K< ?8B0O9AO ;>2><, >B=N4L =5-7028AOI B ?>25;5=89 3@04A:8E 8->B-2AO:8O =C64K 4@C38O. K;8 8-<=OI85, GB> G5;>25:, C2>;L=5==K9 =>2>, 0: 8AE>4O9 >B-@01>B 65AB>:8E 2A5340H=8 =52>;8, >;59 GC2AB2C5B 2A5E 4@C38E >= A;04>ABL A2>1>4K. =0:>=5F 8=K5, GB>-B> G5;>25:, :>9-?@8-A<5@B8, "5< GB> >=>3> @>: >B-2A53> A2>1>6405B :>=5G=>, G5;>25:8 2A5 =04 =8< =5-8<5NB-C6 2;0AB8. /, 2 <>N G@54C, >B25I0;, =5->?=C2H8AL =8-<0;>, 0: =5-701K2H89, GB>-5=B>@ >-B><-<=5 3>20@820; G0AB>: «>;L=59H89 2A5E, O-A:070;, :B> 2>;5= 2 A0<>9 =52>;5. 45 1 8-:0:>2 :B>-=8-1K;, ?@5A2>1>45= B>B ?@51K205B, A;8 1>8BAO 1>3>2, 8 B>:<>-GB> >=KE 1>8BAO: !;>2><, ?>8AB8=5 2>;5= B>B, :B>, 2AO:>3> AB@0E0 'C64 8 2A5E ?@8E>B59, 1>30< 8 @07C77@5;8 =0-4@C30 4@C3 >A:;01;OOAL, C4828;8AL >=8, GB>->B25B <>9 B>G=> 8=>52. @54;>65=0 ?>B>< 4@C30O 7040G0 2 A;>20E A8E: B> =5AG0AB=59H89 5ABL 87 2A5E G5;>25:>2 2>-A25B5? 064K9 A:07K20; B0:, :0:-A2>8< >= @07C<>< B 3>2>@8;, GB> :B> =51>30B, =574>@>2 8-=5G5AB5=. !59 A>45@60;, GB> =5B C-:>3> =8 548=>3> 4@C30. = 87@5:, GB>->B5F, C :>B>@>3> 45B8 B0:85, >8 =5 1;03>40@=K 5 =54>AB>9=K. K; AB@>20 5A2>=0, B0: ?@>25I02H89: «!0-A51O ?>G8B05B =5AG0AB=0, 1> =5AG0AB8O =5B 2 25I0E 87=C@ONI8E AB>;L:>, !:>;L:> B>3> 2 =5B5@?5=88 ?@8C<=>60NI5< >=>». !;KH0 A85, A>1@0=85 2AQ 2>A:;8:=C;> 3@><:>, A5 2>A?;5A:0;8 5 A59-G5ABL >45@68B. > 2>?@>H5=-1K; 8-O, 2 >B25B 8< A:>@> A:0702H89, !;54CO ?@028;0< B5<, =0CG8;AO >B-5=B>@0 :>8<, 'B> 2> 2A5E G5;>25:0E 5ABL B> F0@L ?@515AG0AB5=, =8BAO ?@5AG0AB;82 :>9-1KBL, GB> 2 154=>ABL ?@>G8E 225@305B: =, ?>-A2>59 A;5?>B5, 5I5 AC3C1> =5AG0AB;82, 0: =5-<>3CI89 7=0BL A2>53> 6 =5AG0AB8O B>G=0, =5 <>65B ?@8B>< >B-=53> =8:>340 CAB@0=8BLAO, "5< GB>-1>8BAO 2 A515 53> ?>7=0BL A>25@H5==>: AB8=0 ;LABOI8E : =57L-B>;?C =5 <>65B ?@>4@0BLAO. CG8< >=-;NB> 5ABL 2A5340 A2>8<8 AB@0ABO<8; = 87 4>;6=>AB59 2A5E >B=N4L =8 548=K =5-7=05B; !;04>AB8 >= =8:>340 =5-2:CA8; 4>1@0 2 A>B2>@5=8, =8:>340 6 =5-2840; :@0A>BK 2 4>1@>45B5;8 G8AB>9: = 7;>?>;CG5= 2>-2A5<, 8-4>AB>8= 1KBL 7;>?>;CG5=; 064K9 45=L 5= A2>59 1568B, 8-3>B>2OBAO 1>38 =>3> ?@5?>ABK48BL 25;L<8 =0:070=85< 25G=K<. 5AL A>1>@ ?@87=0; ?>15645=0 <=>N ;5A289F0; ?@5AB0@5;K5 1JO28;8, 'B> C;CG8; O B>;:>< 2 8AB8==K9 @07C< 8=>52. * * * @5645 6 2A5E 8=KE, =5G5AB820O B0 AB0@25O, "K >-:>B>@>9 A;KE0;, 1K2 2 "8@5, <=>3064K AB>;L:>, A5@4F5 A2>5< ?>3C18BL F0@O 2>7=0<5@8;0AL B25@4>. !B@0AB=> ;N18;0 >=0 548=>3> N=>HC B8@A:0, G5=L 1>30B0 8-:@0A=0, 8<5=5< >070@0. "0 E>B5;0 A53> =0-?@5AB>; ?>A048BL 2>F0@82H8. 'B>-6-1K 2 =0<5@5=8 A5< ?>;CG8BL CA?5E 2>645;5==K9, "> 2A:;525B0;0 F0@N 87 42CE =0 AB0@H53> AK=0, -65;0O =5B5@?5;82=> KBL ?@55<=8: >BFC A2>5 7;>-C6=KE A2845B5;59 B0 ?>4AB028;0, 8 4>:070;0. &0@L C<5@B28; A2>53> =5?>28==>3> AK=0 15AG0AB=>. ;04H89, 0;5070@ =0@8F05A;0= 2 !0<>= 1K;, C4B> 1 =0C:0< 59-65 25I8, :0: AB0@25O F0@N =0H5?B0;0, 'B> =04;560;> 53> C40;8BL, 40-=5->= A>3;0A8BAO 40-=5-2ABC?8B B0:>645 2 7;K9 A =54>2>;L=K<8 C?;K; A59 5420, :0:-:>@01;L A =8< 254H85 ;N48, K2H8 ?>4:C?;5=K 2A5 >B-B>O 6 65=K ?@5;8E8O, @8=O;8 <5@K B>B ?>B>?8BL 2> 2@5I=>5. !0<8 A?0A;8AL 4>-GC68E ;0459 2?;02L, 8E >68402H8E; "0:-B> F0@528G0 B5 2 3;C18=C <>@A:CN =8725@3;8. ?@>G5<, ;N1>2L AB0@258=0 B0 =5 254><0 B>:<> 83<0;8>=C 1K;0 >4=>= 2=CB@5==> 4C<0;, 'B> =8:>3> 4@C3>3> >=0 =8:>340 =5-?>;N18B. !59 3>AC40@L, =54>25@G82K9 B>;L, ?>25@8;AO A;5?> ;>9-A59 65=5, GB>-;N1>2L >A;5?8;0 53> ?@5157<5@=>. ">G=> 2 B>-6-2@5;N15=, 8A:0;->= ?>4;>3>2, 'B>1 8AB@518BL 1>30B>3> >=>3> >070@0, >53> B0: AB0@25O 8-B>;L G@572KG09=> ;N18;0: AQ 1>30BAB2> E>B5;-F0@L C-N=>H8 B>:<> 2>AE8B8BL. > :0: 83<0;8>= ?@51K20; :>@KAB8N 3=CA=> ?>4>7@5=8N, 8 ;N128, 8 0;G=>AB8 : 7;0BC, "> AB0@25O >B=OBL C-=53> 682>B ?>A?5H8;0. =8;0, GB>-<>65B-1KBL =5A:>;L:> >= C65 4>3040;AO ;N1>459AB25 15AG5AB=>< 55 A B5<-<;04K< G5;>25:><. 540;0 A25@LE, ?@54>2>;L=C 1KBL A@51@>;N18N B>:<>, ;NB>AB8 GB>1 ?>=5AB8AL F0@N =0 >070@0. "0: 70:;NG8;0 2 A515, GB>-B5@OBL =8-G0A0-59 =5-4>;6=> ?>B@518BL 53> A0<>3> C?@5645=85< A<5@B8. 845;0 B0 =0G0;L=KE ;N459 2 ?0;0B5, 3>B>2KE C:8 A2>8 >103@8BL ?@>;8O=85< F0@A:8O :@>28. !;KH0;0 45=L =0 2AO: > =5:>5< C2><, ">:<> 6 1>O;0AL ?>25@8BL 2 A2>5< G5;>25:C B0:>B>@K9 2>7<>65B 59 ?@540B5;5< 2 45;5. > =0:>=5F 25AL<0 157>?0A=55 B>9 ?>:070;>AL, /4>< 2B09 >:>@<82H8, 8725ABL B5< 83<0;8>=0. CH820; >= =08G0I5 >48=, 8;L A >=>N B>:<>: !0< 8-3>B>28; 2AQ ?@>-A51O, GB> :CH0BL-1K; 4>;65=, 5@8BL 2 A5< =8 GL8<, :@><5 A2>8E-@C:, =5-<>3H8. = 70:;NG0;AO 2 ?0;0B0E A2>8E 2 >B40;5==59H5 <5AB>, CGH5 401K C:@KBL 525@:C B0:CN =5 1KBL-1K =8:5< =8:>340 =078@05, AB2C :>340 : AB>;C A2>520@. !;04>AB59 C6 =8:0:8E =5 A<5; 8A:0BL->= 70AB>;L=KE: 0-8-=5-<>3 2:CA8BL, A0<-G53> =5-C<5; 873>B>28BL. "0: =5 B>:<> , > 8-5I5 28=>, <;5:>, E;51, A>;L-65 8-<0A;>, AO:0 ?8I0 ?@8B>< 8-4@C30O, 2A5< >1KG09=0, KBL =5-<>3;8 >B=N4L 5B@51C AB>;>2C. ; >= B>;L:> ?;>4K, 2 A04C A 4@52 A>@20=K 8< 65, ;L >3>@>4=K9 7;0:, :>B>@K9 A0<-65 =0A5O; C-A51O 20@8; B5< >1@07><, A:070==K< <=>N. ?@>G5<, =5 CB>;O;-65 8-6064K 4@C3>N 2>4>N, ">:<> :>B>@CN A0< ?>G5@?=5B 87-:;0457O, 1K2H0 =5:>5< <5AB5 ?0;0BK, 2A5340 6 70<:=5==0 ?@5:@5?:>; :;NG8 >B-70<:>2 ?@8-A515 8<5; A>E@0=OO. >;L =8-O2;O;AO 6 =045645= 1KBL =0-A2>N AB0@25N, ">:<> 8 >B-=55 =5?@5AB0==> ?@54>E@0=O;AO. @5645 A51O 8 5ABL 8 ?8BL 70AB02;820; >=C 7 2A53>, =0-AB>;5 C =8E B0< GB> =8-AB>O;>, 'B>1 5B@02;5=C O4>< ?> =5<-1K A0<>9 =5 68BL 59 4>;59 =0-A25B5. > ?@8=O;0 =0?5@54-B0 ?@>B82=>5 75;L5 >B@025, >8< AB0@CE0 55 A=0148;0, 7;59H0 A0 2A5E ;N1>459=KE 15A?CBAB20E: >A;5 G53> ?>3C18BL F0@O C65 =5-1>O;0AL. !5 8 A?>A>1, :0:8< 7;>45O=85 B> A>25@H8;0: G0A, >=8 70-AB>;>< 2 :>B>@K9 =0G0;8 :CH0BL, "0 AB0@CE0, ?>A>1I8F0 59, ?>N, 4@C3 703@5<5;0 25;8:8< ABC:>< ?@8-=5:>8E 425@OE. &0@L, <=O-2A5340, GB>-C189FK : =5<8BLAO E>B5;8, 5AL AB0=>28BAO A ;L >=8 25AL<0 70:;NG5=K 70?>@0<8 1K;8. ">BG0A AB0@CE0 CH;0. &0@L 2 =54>C<5=88 AB0; 1KBL, =5 7=0;, GB> -A;KH0==>< ABC:5 8-3@><5, ">;L:> 6 425@59 >B2>@8BL =5-?>A<5; >A<>B@8BL-1K ?@8;56=59. B>< >1>4@O5B 53> AB0@25O, 8-:C?=> ;0A:05B, 0 8 ?0:8 70-AB>; ?@87K205B, 8-?@>A8B ?>:CH0BL. /4 C6->=0 2;>68;0 <564C B5< 2 G0HC 7;0BCN, 530; >= :>340 :> 425@O<, ?@8-:>8E ABCG0;>. 83<0;8>=, :0:->1K:, 25;5; 59 ?@5645 =0?8BLAO. K?8;0 B0 =5-1>OAL, =0-?@8OB> ;5:0@AB2> 2 =045645. 8; >=-8-A0<; 8 2A:>@5 ?>B>< 5H=8;>AL, B>BG0A-65 C?0; BCB 2 ><@0:. > AB0@25O, =0O, GB>-<>65B 55 C18BL A ?>4>7@5=8O <=59H0, !B0;0 >4564C 4@0BL =0-A515 8 2>;>AK A 2>5<. >B >1J5<;5B F0@O C<8@0NI0; 2>B ?@868<05B; >B >:@>?;O5B 53> 8-?>B>:>< A;57 4>645;82=KE: 1> E8B@0O B0, ;8HL-70E>G5B, B>-A;57K 8-;LNBAO. 0:-65 C2845;0 B0< =0:>=5F, GB> F0@L >15AA8;5; :0: 1C4B> A 4CE>< A2>8< C65 @0AAB020;AO, ">, 40-=5-2-?025;8B C<5@B28BL-BC A A>1>N, 0A:8 A2>8 >AB0282H8 2A5 8-CA5@48O 7=0:8, >AB5@25=82HCAO O@>ABL ?@8H;0 C60A=> 8-AB@0==>. @>A8;0AL B0 =0-=53>, 8-B>340 704028;0 @C:0<8. "0:-B> C<-=0H =8-AC4L18=K A515, =8-2?@54L-1C4CI8 G0AB8, 0 8-=8-<5@ =5 7=05B AG0AB85< ?@52>7=5A5==K9! 5@AB5=L ?>B>< A>@20;0 A @C:8, A 3>;>2K 6 48048070@C, >5 4804868;0. =8;0, GB>-1K2H85 2A5 A AB>@>=K 55 =5-70<54;OB !;54>20BL AB@0AB8 55 6 8-F0@5< ?@>?>254OB ;N18 =08?0G5 E>B52H85 B>9 C3>640BL 2 @01>;5?AB25 >4;K 8<5;8 A5@4F0, :>@KABL ;N18;8 15745;L=C, =5 A?>A>1=K >B=N4L : CA5@48N 8A:@5==N 1K;8, !25@LE-65 B>3> 2> 2A5E 2 =8E =5 1K;> 1>4@>AB8 A<5;K, >?0A0;8AL 2@03>2, AB0@25O :>B>@KE 8<5;0. >;LH5 1>O;8AL 5I5, GB>-65=0 A8O =5G5AB820, 0: 3>@40 =5A=>A=> 1K;0, B0:-;NB0, 7;0-8-A:@KB=0: 064K9 65;0;, 2 157>?0A=>ABL A515, 401K B0-?>381;0. B>< ?@8-42>@5 8-2-?0;0B0E AAB0; ?@525;8:89, !;KH8BAO 2AN4C :@8:: «&0@O =5 AB0;>! !:>=G0;AO!» "5 CAB@0H8;8AL; 4@C385 E20B0NB >@C685 A?5H=>; !;54AB289 1>OBAO 2A5, 0-GB>-C<5@ F0@L =5-3>@NNB. 5ABL ?>;5B5;0 >-A5<, >B CAB : CAB0< ?@5;5B0;0, A>1>9 >3;0A8;0 25AL-3@04 2:@C3 "8@ ?@525;8:89; ">;L:> 6 =865 >4=>3> =5-=0H;>AL ?@8B>< G5;>25:0, >9-1K BC68; ?> F0@5, 874>EH5< A:>@>?>AB86=>: !<5@BL 53> A?0A5=85 2A5< 8 ;N4O< CB5E0. * * * >;6=> ;N459 ?@8<5G0BL ?@8;56=>, 40->=KE ?>7=05HL. '0AB>-8E 2845BL 4>;3 8-15A54>20BL <=>3064K A =8<8. 04>1=>, GB>1 F0@8 3>2>@8;8 A ?>42;0AB=K<8 A0<8; 04>1=>, GB>1 3>2>@8BL ?>4G8=5==KE >=8 70AB02;O;8; !?@0H820BL > 45;0E C =8E A>25B>2 8-<=5=89; A?KB>20BL B5E-A0<8E =5-1>;LH8<8 B0:65 45;0<8, :>8E-1K >B?>254L B5 F0@O< 4020;8 8A?@02=C, 0 C284OBAO, ACBL-;8 A?>A>1=K : 4>;6=>ABO< 2KAH8<. '5<, "8;5<0E ;N157=K9, BK =0CG8;AO 2 D0:5 0A?>7=020BL 4>1@>BK @07=L 2 20O==KE :C<8@0E? '0ABK< 2845=85< A8E, 8-?@8B>< =01;N45=85< B25@4K< A5E ?>@>:>2, 8-2-=8E A>25@H5=AB2, A 8A:CA=K<8 2 45;5 1@07>< @02=K< 15A54C9, 8 @073>20@8209 G0AB> 1;038E 8 :0G5AB20E 7;KE 2 G5;>25:0E A 4@C38<8 "K G5;>25:8, AB8 8 4>1@>45B5;59 25AB=KE, >8 4>;38< 8A:CAAB2>< B5E 8-?>7=0;8 8A?KB=>; "0: =5GC2AB28B5;L=> A0< ?>7=05HL 8-BK ?@54>2>;L=>, !CBL :0:>2K >=8 8-G53> >B =8E 640BL-?@8AB>8B. 'B> =0CG8;> B51O ?>7=020BL 87@O4=> 8-B>G=> >1@KE B5E, 8-EC4KE, 8 ?>A@54AB25==KE B>:<> ?88B>2? '0AB>5 GB5=85 8E, 8-A ;N4L<8 @0AAC645=85 B0:65, =0NB A8;C :>B>@K 2>-2A5E AB8E>B2>@G5AB20 @>40E, 'B> ?>:070;> B515 @0718@0BL 2 ABL? ">6 ?@8;560=85 2AQ : =01;N45=8N 2 4>1@KE. 0: 2>7<>6=> =045OBLAO ?@028BL ;N4L<8 ?@587@O4=>, 65;8 ACBL B515 2A5:>=5G=> =5254>7=0BL, :>340 =5B->1I5=8O A =8<8? "> =5->1I0BLAO A =8<8, GB>-2845BL 8E 2A5=0@>4=>: B>1>N4C BCB 3>2>@OBAO A@54=85 25I8, ?@83>B>2;5=K B5 ?@8:@0A0<8 E8B@K<8 B>G=>. >;3 =0548=5 2845BL 8E, 872;5:0BL 2A5-87-A5@4F0 "09=K C1568I0 B5E, ?@8:0A0BLAO : >=K< >B2AN4C C3;C1;OBLAO 2 =8E, 40->B:@>5BAO 2=CB@5==>ABL A0<0. > 401K @0AAC640BL > ;N4OE 8A?@02=> 8-?@O<>, "> =0G8=0BL-4>;3 A ?>7=0=8O, 1KBL-8< :0:8< 5ABL-?@8@>4=>: 04>1=> 7=0BL, 5ABL GB>-B> 4>AB>9=>ABL ACI0 8-B25@40, 0 @07;8G0BAO 8B-A5O =582>@OB >-4>AB>9=>AB8 8 4>1@>45B5;8 702A5; =5 7=0NB 5ABL-GB> 4>AB>9=>ABL 8 4>1@>45B5;L. @0A=K-B> @5G8 B>:<>, A;>20 8-@071@>4G82K <=>38E, >8 2 G5ABL-AB02OB A515 3>2>@8BL > =8E ?>2A5G0A=>. >;6=> 8<5BL >A=>20=8O 25@=K >-?@0245, 8-:C?=> 4>1@>45B5;8, 8 > @07C<5 B0:65 @0AAC4=><, 'B>1 ?>7=0BL, 4>1@>45B5;L=K 8 @07C<=K :>B>@K. 04>1=> ?@028;0 7=0BL ?@028B5;LAB20 4>1@0 8-7=05HL ;N459, 8<5NI8E ?@028;0 >=K, ;N459, >B40;5==KE >B-A8E ?> B>=:>ABO< ;>6=K<. !;>2><, 401K B5;0 87<5@OBL <=>385 25@=>, >;6=> 8<5BL >4=C 8 BC ?>AB>O==CN <5@C: "0:, 8-401K @0AAC640BL, 4>;3-8<5BL 4>AB>25@=K =0G0;0, 0 :>B>@KE AC645=8O< =0H8<-2A5< B25@4> 1 A=>20BLAO. >;3-7=0BL, :0:0O F5;L G5;>25G5A:8 687=8 2A5>1I8, >9 8-:>=5F ?@54;030BL G5;>25:>2 2 ?@02;5=88 4>;6=>. &5;L 548=AB25==0 8 ACI5AB25==0 B>:<> A8O 5ABL, 5 E>B5BL =8:>340 4;O-A51O =8-25;8G89 =8-2;0AB8: "> G5AB>;N185 B>:<> B8@0=A:CN 3>@4>ABL =0AKB8B; > =04;568B ?@54020BL A51O B@C40< 15A?@545;L=K<, 'B>1 A>45;0BL ;N459 8 4>1@KE 8 1;03>AG0AB=KE. =0:>, >IC?>< 845B 2AO:, 8-?>-A;CG0N A;5?C; ">6 G@57 2AQ A2>5O ?@>4>;65=85 F5;KO 687=8. 45B @02=> :0:-=5:89 :>@01;L =0-?CG8=5 ?@>AB@0==>9, 5B =0-:>B>@>< 8A:CA=>3> :>@B>@>< A>725748O< 8 =01;N45=89 =515A=K<, "0:65 :>B>@>65B 3>=7=CBL >B-@0718B89 8 ?>B>?;5=89. =>385 G0AB> 87 3>AC40@59, =5-7=0O 8A?@02=>, G5< A>AB>8B 4>1@>45B5;L ACI0O, ?@O<> =5-7=0NB, >;6=> G53> 8A:0BL 8< ?5@259 2>-2A5E G5;>25:0E. AB8==0 2AO 4>1@>45B5;L 4;O-=8E 5ABL =5:0: AC@>20: 065BAO >=0O 8< ?@587;8H=> 1KBL =5?>42;0AB=0; "0 ?@82>48B-8E 2 AB@0E, 8-5I5 ?@525AL<0 >3>@G05B; "0: >1@0I0NBAO 2A5 >=8 : ;0A:0=8N A;04:C. ! A0<>3> 65 G0A0 A53> C6 1>;59 =5-<>3CB A:@5==>ABL 2 :>< 87>1@5ABL 8 B25@4CN BC 4>1@>45B5;L: ! A0<>3> 65 8-G0A0 A53> 153CB 70-?@87@0:>< "I5B=K< 55, :>B>@K9 B>G=>-5ABL ;>6=0O A;020, ?>-:>B>@>AB>9=K. ">BG0A C65 ?@8B>< >1K:0NB B25@4> 8-25@8BL, 'B> 4>1@>45B5;8 ACI8O =5B =0-75<;5 2A5:>=5G=>: 1> 4>1@K5 7=0NB 7;KE 4>2>;L=> 87@O4=>, ;K5 6 =5-7=0NB >B=N4L 2A5E 4>1@KE A5@4F5< 8-=@02><, "0: 8 25@8BL =5-<>3CB, GB>1-A88 2?@O48;8AL. A5 3>AC40@8 B0:85 B>:<> 2A5<-@02=> =5-25@OB: @>NBAO B5< >B 2A5E >=8, 2 A515 70:;NG0OAL; ">BG0A ?@85<;NB ?>47>@ >B A0 1>OBAO ;N459, 8 A0<8 8E CAB@0H0NB. 530NB A25B0, 2 A2>59 8-?@8@>45 O2;OBLAO =5-A<5NB. >;L-65 >=8 E>BO =5-65;0NB 1KBL-254>G8<, > 2A5340 1K20NB, >4=0:>, 2AO:> ?>42;0AB=KE 8< ;N1>?KBAB2>, :@09=> ;C:02>, @5?@>=8F05B 2AQ, 8 2AQ C304K20BL <>65B, >=8 ?@8B>< =8:>3> 87 >=KE =5-7=0NB. N1OI8 ;N48 :>@KABL, :>B>@K 2A5340 >1;560B 8E, 04K B>->=8 =5?@8ABC?=K 1K20NB: &0@L =5?@8ABC?5= ;N4O<, 8-?@0245 5ABL->= =5?@8ABC?5=. >6=> G5@=OB-B5 ?@54-=8< 7;>459A:8<8 2AQ :;525B0<8, >B40;ONB >G8 5A25B8BL 2>7<>3CI8E. !88 F0@8 ?@>2>640NB 687=L 2 25;8G88 48:><, :>5<, 1>OAL 15A?@5AB0=8 >1<0=CBK 1KBL CE8I@5==>, !CBL 2 >1<0=5 2A5340 =5<8=C5<><; 40 8-4>AB>9=>. 8HL CB25@4OBAO, A>25BK ?@8<0BL ;N459 >B-=5<=>38E; A0<>5 2@5 6 2>A?@8<0BL >1O7CNBAO B0:65 =KE 2A5-AB@0AB8 8 701;C645=8O ;>6=K5 :C?=>: 1> 8-4>1@K5 ;N48 A2>8 ?>@>:8 8<5NB. !25@LE-65 B>3>, ?@540NBAO >=8 >1>;30B5;O< 2?>;=5. >4;>4C 8-7;><, AQ >B@02;ONIC, GB> 15A?>@>G=> 8-5ABL =5?>28==>, 0;K5 A04OIC 2 1>;LH85, 7>1@5B0NIC ?0G5 7;>, 0 =5 ?@5AB0NIC A5E 2@548BL ?>2A5340 8-A<5NICAO, @048 ?@81KB:0, 0: =54>25@=>AB8, B0: 8-=53>4=>;L ;N1>?KBAB2C A;01>< B0:>< 3>AC40@5, 8 B>;8:> ?C6;82><. "0: ?>7=0209 65, >! "8;5<0E 4@0389 8-;N157=K9, A5E ?>7=0209-BK ;N459. !2845B5;LAB2C9 A0<-8E ?@8;56=>; >25;5209 >4=8< 3>2>@8BL >-4@C38E ?@54-B>1>N; >@>7=L 87254K209 B5E =5 24@C3, 40->B<0;0 ?><0;C; 5 ?>;0309AO =8 =0-:>3> A 2>7;N1;5=8O 2OI0; ?KBK C?>B@51;O9 2>-B2>N =04;560ICN ?>;L7C, C45 :>340 2 B2>8E AC645=8OE 1K;-BK >1<0=CB, 1> 8<55HL 1KBL 8=>340 >1<0=CB :>=5G=>: ;K5 B>;L 3;C1>:8, C;>2;OBL GB> <>3CB 2A5<5@=> >1@KE >=8 A2>8<8 ?@8B2>@AB2K 8 ;8F5<5@AB2K. G@57 B> =0CG8AL =5-AC48BL =8->-:>< ?@5?>A?5H=>, 8 ?>-4>1@C, =865 8-?>-EC4C GB> CB25@640O: "> 8-4@C3>5 25AL<0-5ABL 8A?>;=5=> 154AB289 ?@5<=>38E. !8< ?>3@5H=>AB8 ?@>H;K B2>8 B515 6 ?@5?>;57=> 5 ?@5<8=CB ?>40BL =0AB02;5=85 2?@54L =0-?>?@02C. A;8 6 BK 87>1@OI5HL B0;0=BK 8 4>1@>45B5;L =5:>5< B5E 87 2A5E G5;>25:>2, 872540==KE B>G=>, "> 53> 8 C?>B@51;O9 A =04564>N : 45;C, 1> 65;0NB ;N48, 8<5NI8 ?@02>5 A5@4F5, 0 ?@02>B0 8E 2AO >ICI05<0 O2AB25==> 1C45B: CGH5 ;N18B5;L=>ABL 8< 8-4>25@5==>ABL 2AO:8E A>:@>28I. > =5 ?>@BL-8E 225@5=85< 8< 15A?@545;L=KO A8;K. 5:B> 2A5340 1 B>B 1K; 4>1@>45B5;5=, :>9 =5-B0:>2 C6, "5<-GB> 5AC40@L 40;-157<5@=CN 2;0ABL 8-1>30BAB2>. B> 4>2>;L=> ;N18<-5ABL 1>30<, GB>-2>-2A5< 3>AC40@AB25 0945B 42CE 8;L B@5E ?@8OB5;59 8AB8==KE ACI5, "> 5ABL AB>O==>; A:>@5 B>B G@57 =8E 8-4@C38E =0E>48B ?>4>1=KE, 0 =0?>;=5=85 <5AB 8=KE, :>B>@K ?>=865. ">:<> G@57-4>1@KE >4=8E, >= :>8< 225@8BAO ?@O<>, >65B ?>7=0BL, G53> A>1>N =5 ?>7=0205B, !CBL :0:>2K 2 A515 4@C385 >=K >A>1K. * * * 5=B>@ ?>B>< 2>AE>B5; 8A?KB0BL, C65 =0>AB0B>:, A8;L=O9 5I5, B5@?5;82=>ABL BC 2 "8;5<0E5. A0B-G0A, :0: N=K9 E>B5; 84B8 ?@5?>A?5H=> C48BL 2A5E <>@5E>4F52 : ?>?;KB8N 157 70<54;5=89, 5=B>@ 53> 24@C3 >AB0=>28;, 8-?@8=C48; =0-1@535 5@B2C 25;8:C ?@8=5ABL ?@59 1>38=5 0;;045. "> "8;5<0E, GB> 5=B>@ 25;8B, 8A?>;=O5B ?>A;CH=>. !5 87 45@=0 AC3C1K9 >;B0@L ?>AB02;O5BAO 2A:>@5; !5 D8<80< 2>A:C@O5BAO; :@>2L B5G5B 87-70:;0==KE: !5 "8;5<0E ?@5B5?;C <>;L1C ?@>;8205B-BCB : =51C, 0: ?@87=020O9 A8;L=K9 ?>:@>2 A515 >B-1>38=8. 5@B25 5420 A>25@H82H59AO, A5 8-70-5=B>@>< 845B @0G=K<8 2AN4C AB57O<8 2 @>I8F5, 1;87 >BAB>O2H59. !5 >ICI05B B0<, GB>-;8F5 ?@5AB0@5;>3> 4@C30 1@07 ?@85<;5B =>2! >@I8=K A G5;0-2A5 A=8:0NB, 0: 8AG5705B BL<0, >B-45==8FK 103@O=K<8 ?5@ABK AB>:0 2@0B0 >B25@70NI8 8 ?@>;820NI8 A25B;>ABL. ?04H85 B5 6 8-AC@>2K5 A5 ?@5<5=ONBAO >G8 >G8 C65 3>;C1K5, F25B0 8-A25B0 =515A=0, 2 ?@58A?>;=5==K 60@:8E 8A:@ 1>65AB25==> =5:0:. !540 1@040 =52848<0 5ABL. '5@BK 1;03>@>4=K, > 8-A0=>2=K, ?@8OB=>ABL<8 6 =56=K<8 2A5 A@0AB2>@5==K, "CB "8;5<0E0 >G0< ?@54JO2;ONBAO ?@5?><@0G5==K<. 848B B>340 >=-;8F5 65=K 25;5<>I=KO ;5?>, ;04:> 8-A25B;> B0:, :0:-F25B>:, >A8O==K9 >B-A>;=F0. @8==0-15;L 7@8BAO =0-=5< ?@8-H8?:>2 @CAB8 A25659. A5< =0-;8F5-B>< 83@05B <;04>ABL 2A5340H=OO 25G=>, @8 25;8G88 6 :0: ?@>AB><, B0: =5 CE8I@5==><. ;8==K 2;0AK 8AB>G0NB 4CE 2>=8 0<2@>A89=K, 87K A8ONB 55 B0:8<8 <0AB59 8A?5I@5=L<8, !>;=F5 :0:8<8 2:@C3, ?@8-A2>5< 2>AB5G5=88 2 CB@>, A5 >70@O5B <@0G=K5 :@>2K >=K =515A=K, C?=> 8-G5@=K5 BCG8, >=> GB>-B>340 ?>7;0I05B. "0 1>65AB25==>ABL BCB 75<;8 =5-:0A0;0AL AB>?0<8: 53:> ?0@8B >=0 ?>-2>74CEC, :0:-:@8;0 8I=>N 45@68B @C:>N B0 6 :>?85 ?@51;5I0I5, B@5?5B <>3CI5 ?@825ABL 8 3@04K 8-@0B=K =0@>4K: !0< 8-@0482 1K 25AL >B-B>3> ?@5A>4@>3AO 2A5<5@=>. ;0A 55 B8E, <5@5=, => ?@>@078AB> O@>:. 5G8 >=K5 2A5, :0: AB@5;K >3=5==K =5:8, !5@4F5 2AQ ?@>=8F0NB 2=CB@L B>340 2 "8;5<0E5 40NB 5ICI0BL 1>;L =5:89 ?@8OB=K9. @8BAO =0-H;5<5 55 =>I=0O ?B8F0 0D8=A:0; =0 ?5@AOE C-=59 M384-BCB A25@:05B ?@5AB@0H=K9 =0:0< ?>-A8< "8;5<0E ?@87=0; C4>1=> 0;;04C. « 1>38=O! B0:-BK-B> A0<0 C4>AB>8;0 A:@KB=> KBL @C:>2>4=8F59 AK=C, A ;N128 : >BFC 48AA5N! >;L ;CG570@=0! :>;L<8 6 87<5=8;0AL >B-5=B>@0! O25 K2H0 A?>A?5H=8:0 <=5 8-2>-2A5< =0AB02=8:0 A2OB0! >;L-65 <>O 8-=045640 2AO =0-CA?5E ?CB5H5AB289, ><>I8 >B B2>5O, 1;0609H0, 7028A5;0 B25@4>!» >;LH5 E>B5; ?@>25I0BL, =>-5. "I5B=> CAB=5 53> : 87JO2;5=8N A8;8;8AL 4OI8E A5@45G=K "0< ?@8ACI0 1>65AB25==>ABL >=>3> ?@5CB5A=O;0; K; >= :0: G5;>25:, 2 A=5 >BO3>I5==K9 B>;8:>, 'B> =8-4KH0BL =5-8<55B A8;, 0-2@0I0=85< B@C4=K< #AB A2>8E =5 <>65B C65 ?@>3;03>;0BL =8-A;>20. B><, =0:>=5F, 0;;040 A0<0 87@5:;0, ?@>25I0O: «!K= 48AA552! ?>A;CH09 <5=O, 8-A85-C6 2?>A;54=8. / =8:>3> =5-CG8;0 87-A<5@B=KE A @045=85< 1>;LH8<, >;L B51O. /-B51O 25;0 A:2>7L 154AB20 @C:>N, > =58725AB=K< AB@0=0<, 2> 1@0=5E ?@5:@>2>;8B=KE 2 7;>:;NG5=8OE 2AO:8E, :>B>@K <>3CB =5;>6=> !5@4F5 2AQ 8A?KB0BL, 8 B> 8A:CA8BL 2 G5;>25:5. / ?>:070;0 B515, G@57-GC2AB28B5;L=K >?KBK A0 8-;>6=K, :0:-F0@AB2CNB 2 ;N45E A5 B2>8 ?>3@5H=>AB8 1K;8 =5-<5=LH5 ?>;57=K, ?@54L : ?>?@025 B515, :>;L-B2>8 6 8-=5AG0AB8O <=>38. 1> :B> G5;>25:-5ABL, <>389 45@602AB2>20BL , 65;8 >= =8:>340 =8:0:8E =5-AB@040; 7;>:;NG5=89 =5-C<5; 65 C?>B@518BL AB@040=89-B5E 2 ?>;L7C, :>8 ?>3@5H=>AB8 B>G=> 53> 2A5340 =8725@30;8? "K =0?>;=8;, :0:-B2>9 8->B5F, <>@O-2A5 8-75<;8 =>38<8 B>;L ?@8:;NG5=L<8, 8-B5<8 ?5G0;L=K<8 2A5<8. K=5 848: ?>-53> AB57O< 84B8-BK 4>AB>8=; @0B:89 8-;53:89 ?@5574 >AB0;AO B515 4>-D0:8, = 2 :>B>@CN 2 G0A A59 A02>:C?=> A@0609AO; 5-2A5< ?>28=C9AO "0:, :0: A0A;54=89 87-2A5E 53> ?>4G8=5==KE, 1@07 A>1>9 ?>40O 4@C38< A>45;K20BL B>645. >7L<5B->= >B@>:>28FC 2 AC?@C3C B515 =B8>?C; BK, 2:C?5 682O A =59, 1C45HL AG0AB;82 25@LE>2=>, "5<-GB>-BK 2 >=>9 <=55 8A:0; :@0A>BK >A>1;82K, >;L C<0, 4>1@>45B5;8 8 ?@5?>E20;L=KO G5AB8. C45HL :>340 A0< F0@AB2>20BL BK =0-?@5AB>;5 45@602=>, "> 2 G5ABL AB02L 8-E20;C 2>7=>2;5=85 25:0 7;0B>3>. !;CH09 2A5E; 0 A;CH0O 2A5E B0:, 25@L-BK =5-<=>38<, 1;N48AL A515 A0<>G=> 25@8BL. >9AO >1<0=CB 1KBL; =>->B=N4L =8:>340-BK =5-1>9AO 845BL 4020BL 4@C38<, GB>-:>=5G=> 1K;-BK >1<0=CB. "2>9 =0@>4 ;N18, 8 BI8AL >B-=53>-1KBL ;N18
2008 Litra.ru = Сочинения + Краткие содержания + Биографии
Created by Litra.RU Team / Контакты